Skip to content
July 9, 2025

Amber Duncan On Why ‘Tough Love’ Doesn’t Work on Gen Z and Millennials in Debt

Amber Duncan On Why ‘Tough Love’ Doesn’t Work on Gen Z and Millennials in Debt
Photo Courtesy: Life After Debt

By: Life After Debt

Given the multiple recessions, stock market crashes, and economic turmoil that Millennials, and to a certain extent Gen Z, have already experienced in their lifetime, it stands to reason that they might be more cautious about ‘traditional’ financial advice. In fact, research shows that 75% of Gen Z report experiencing negative mental health effects due to money stress (Payless Power, 2025), yet common solutions remain outdated and may not fully address the challenges of today’s economic environment: skipping a trip to Starbucks, cutting back on discretionary spending, and simply waiting for things to improve.

This disconnect suggests that Life After Debt, founded by financial advocate Amber Duncan, is reevaluating the traditional approach. With millions in consumer debt resolved, Duncan’s team offers not just strategies but also emotional support; a space where debt isn’t viewed as a shameful topic, and healing is considered a part of the process.

The Legacy of Mistrust

These younger generations grew up amid financial upheavals—the 2008 housing crash, mounting student debt, stagnant wages, and most recently, a global pandemic. As they entered adulthood, they found themselves navigating an economic system that no longer rewards loyalty or hard work in the same way it once did.

For them, debt isn’t just a number. It can be a symbol of ongoing instability. Traditional advice, often designed for a different economic climate, frequently reduces financial recovery to behavior modification. However, Millennials and Gen Z may need more than discipline; they may benefit from compassion, guidance, and systems that consider the realities of their circumstances.

Rather than simply rejecting old advice, these younger generations are rethinking their relationship with money. They’re asking more nuanced questions: “How does money affect my mental health?” “Why is no one addressing the emotional burden of debt?” “Where can I find an emotional roadmap for financial recovery?” These questions reflect a deeper shift, where financial well-being is not just about numbers, but about understanding and managing emotions.

Emotionally Intelligent Financial Support

At Life After Debt, financial support begins with a 15-minute Clarity Call. Unlike traditional financial counseling, which can often feel like a lecture, this conversation creates space for vulnerability, self-advocacy, and forward momentum. Duncan has redefined the power dynamic by encouraging callers to share their reasons for wanting change. This shift helps transform the experience from one that feels intimidating into something more empowering.

It’s this philosophy of meeting people where they are, not where someone thinks they should be, that sets Duncan’s approach apart. For many younger clients, it’s the first time they’ve felt understood in a financial discussion.

From Crisis to Clarity

Amber Duncan’s credibility comes from personal experience. After facing bankruptcy during the 2008 crisis, she didn’t just recover—she reshaped her financial life. Her journey from survival to service became the foundation for Life After Debt, and her belief is straightforward: financial independence is a possibility for everyone, but it begins with letting go of shame.

Through transparent strategies like debt settlement negotiations, legal consumer protections, and customized plans that avoid one-size-fits-all budgets, Duncan’s team has helped thousands regain control. The key isn’t achieving perfection with spreadsheets, but fostering a mindset shift, and early indications suggest this approach is proving successful.

A New Era of Transparency

One of the defining traits of younger generations is their openness about money. From viral “debt confessionals” on TikTok to anonymous salary spreadsheets on Reddit, Millennials and Gen Z are making financial discussions more public than ever. They no longer hide their financial struggles; instead, they’re openly questioning the systems that have contributed to their challenges.

Life After Debt has embraced this cultural shift. Duncan’s content, whether on social platforms or in one-on-one conversations, is candid, personal, and free from unnecessary jargon. She’s not trying to impress financial experts; she’s focused on empowering individuals who feel stuck.

And this approach appears to be effective. As debt becomes a more frequent experience, younger generations aren’t hiding from it. Instead, they are seeking tools and solutions, not lectures or shame.

A Model Built on Empathy

Empathy should be considered a key component in financial discussions. It can be an essential tool to uncover the root causes of debt and create a path forward. When individuals feel like they are in a safe, non-judgmental space, they may be more motivated to understand their situation and take positive steps. This is why Duncan’s model is effective. Clients walk away from the Clarity Call with a personalized plan, concrete numbers, and the reassurance that they’re not alone in their journey.

Duncan’s approach empowers people to ask difficult questions, express fears, and take the next step forward without feeling like they’re being condescended to. Many of her most passionate supporters are women, who are often excluded from traditional financial discussions despite managing household finances at higher rates.

Financial Independence Without Shame

The old narrative about debt—one of failure, recklessness, or irresponsibility—is gradually being replaced. A new narrative is emerging, one in which people fall behind not because of a lack of discipline, but because of life’s unpredictability. In this new narrative, recovery is not only possible, it’s a journey that everyone deserves.

Duncan’s mission extends beyond the numbers. It’s about reshaping the story of money. Through transparency, dignity, and resilience, she is helping people rewrite their financial future. This type of financial content is resonating with many in 2025.

The Invitation to Begin Again

Financial independence shouldn’t be viewed as an unattainable goal; it should be a natural next step in someone’s financial journey. Life After Debt invites those burdened by shame, confusion, or fear to take a different first step. The 15-minute Clarity Call isn’t a sales pitch; it’s an opportunity to pause, reflect, and be honest about one’s situation. It’s a chance to be heard and to begin again with a plan that fits the reality of today’s world.

Because if Millennials and Gen Z are redefining the financial rulebook, it’s time for financial support systems to evolve alongside them.

 

Disclaimer: The content of this article is for informational purposes only and should not be construed as financial advice. Financial situations are unique to each individual, and readers are encouraged to seek personalized advice from a qualified financial professional before making any financial decisions. While the strategies discussed may be effective for some, results can vary, and no specific outcome is guaranteed. Always conduct thorough research and consider your personal circumstances before acting on any financial recommendations.

This article features branded content from a third party. Opinions in this article do not reflect the opinions and beliefs of Kivo Daily.